Not the south pole itself, so much as the thought of China capturing it and causing problems for us and everyone else.
Backing up for a little while, do you remember reading about a Chinese lunar lander called Chang’e 7, first mentioned here in back in April? The lunar lander was set to be launched to the south pole of the moon, in particular the area around Shackleton Crater, a spot that both China and the US are interested in exploring - to the point it's considered some of the most coveted land on the moon. Why? Primarily because its location provides some important its features.
... the high rims of the crater create permanently shadowed regions known as “cold traps,” where it’s thought that water (in the form of ice, of course) and other useful materials may have accumulated over billions of years.
But nobody will know how accurate those predictions are until the first landers get there and either analyze samples, or return them to Earth for those studies.
Chang'e 7 was close to launching in late August (Aug. 23) when the mission was suddenly put on hold for 24 hours, and then cancelled and pushed out into 2027. Very little was said about why they cancelled the mission, the only strong reason quoted was:
“In keeping with the principle of proceeding prudently and reliably, and ensuring absolute success, after a comprehensive assessment it has been determined that the Chang’e 7 mission does not meet the conditions for launch and therefore cannot be carried out during the planned launch window this year.”
As I said at the time, maybe it's just me, but when I read something like that, I get the feeling that either nobody had found a couple of big problems with the launch vehicle or the various payloads (lunar orbiter, lander, rover, and a mini-hopper probe) that were suddenly discovered in the past couple of days, or the mission was nothing but a pile of problems, pencil-whipped every step of the way despite someone somewhere being aware of conditions that. The bottom line is they never should have tried to launch with those problems.
To be fair, an alternate view was given by Eric Berger at Ars Technica, who speculated that the reason for the scrub of Chang'e 7's launch was a typhoon in the vicinity, Typhoon Narra, and that was complicated by the presence of conditions that they wouldn't trust to launch into.
I bring this mission back to your attention because NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman recently expressed concern that if China were to be the first nation to land in Shackleton Crater that they might do their best to block our access to the crater entirely. Both countries have expressed desire to get to the area of Shackleton and explore from there.
Isaacman and other US officials have started to express concerns that China could establish exclusion zones where robotic probes and then human missions go. Chang’e 7 will bring considerable mobility to the Moon.
“[China] has rovers, it has hopper drones like we now have in development but didn’t eight months ago, and could have potentially denied access to some of the most interesting spots,” Isaacman said. “They want to interact with the water ice, and they want to get really good at the skills for where they’ll want to go next for their Neil Armstrong-like moment. Except it won’t be on the Moon, it’ll be on Mars.”
Yet another complication is that no country has successfully landed that close to the lunar south pole (or the north pole, for that matter) and the US has a wild card: Blue Origin's Blue Moon Mark 1. This large lander will carry two NASA probes to the south pole, possibly as early as spring 2027.
Blue Origin's Blue Moon Lander. Image credit: Blue Origin
It's fair to ask if it really matters if China or the US is the first lander on the moon this time. Closing words to Jared Isaacman:
“That will call into question every other country around the world,” Isaacman said of China landing on the Moon next. “Like, whose security guarantee should I trust? Should I trust the United States and NATO? Should I trust China if they’re the emerging technical superpower here? Whose technology should I buy? Whose military hardware should I buy? Whose standards should I adhere to? Who am I listening to on AI? Am I listening to the United States or am I listening to China on that? All of that’s on the table.”
This should never have been a race, Isaacman said, noting US space policy failures going back to the Reagan administration. He estimates that NASA has spent $100 billion across multiple presidential administrations, Democrat and Republican, that has led nowhere. Meanwhile, China just had its first human spaceflight in 2003 and has since expanded its capabilities to the point where it now rivals the United States in space.
“If you come up short with who comes down the ladder first, the impact is felt around the world,” Isaacman said.
Shaded relief image of Shackleton crater at the Moon's south pole, with false-color interior constructed from elevation measurements by the Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter Credit: NASA/GSFC/SVS. Image cropped and reduced in size here to fit with Blogger image requirements.





















