United Launch Alliance (ULA) released a statement today (Wednesday Nov. 18) on the failure of the ULA Leo-1 mission on Sunday. It's inline with what a lot of commenters have been saying, that it was caused by a fuel supply issue in the Vulcan booster stage.
“ULA has completed an initial integrated review of flight data from the Leo 1 launch anomaly that occurred last Sunday,” the company said in a statement. “While work remains to determine cause, preliminary indications are that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines.”
It's worth noting that this is pretty much saying they've ruled out that the failure was caused by the Blue Origin BE-4 engines, saying the problem was with the hardware "farther up in the booster."
This is probably bigger news for Blue themselves than for ULA. After all, the BE-4 engines are used on New Glenn, and the catastrophic explosion of the next New Glenn last May has been tentatively attributed to a main oxygen valve on one of the BE-4 engines.
After this anomaly, Blue Origin retrofitted the main oxygen valve, including for Vulcan missions. Now it’s clear that this retrofit was not implicated in the Vulcan accident. With the preliminary Vulcan investigation having largely exonerated the BE-4 engine, Blue Origin can press ahead with its return-to-flight mission with New Glenn, which could occur as soon as January.
“Following the Vulcan anomaly, Blue Origin immediately worked alongside ULA to review flight data and support the investigation,” Blue Origin said in a statement Wednesday. “Together, we identified that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines. ULA is a valued partner, and we look forward to Vulcan’s return to flight.”
You'll also note that this absolves the Centaur upper stage completely. The Centaur did its best to get itself out of the deficit that the Vulcan booster left it in, but couldn't complete the mission. This is a relief for NASA as well, which recently contracted with ULA to use the Centaur V as its new upper stage for the SLS (Space Launch System) rocket, the main vehicle for the increasing missions to settle on the moon.
Something that hasn't been talked about much is that Sunday's Vulcan mission was the first failure of a Vulcan itself on the fifth flight of the vehicle. While the Vulcan was formally out of commission, that was due to the problems with the Solid Rocket Boosters when two out of four missions had broken nozzles on their SRBs. Those apparently worked to spec this flight.
The ULA Vulcan VC6L rocket lifts off from Cape Canaveral Space Force Station,
Florida, at 12:40 pm local time Sunday. The rocket suffered a failure within
the first 10 minutes. Credit: Manuel Mazzanti/NurPhoto via Getty Images
Unfortunately for ULA, they are left to fly only whatever Atlas Vs they have on hand and those are all committed to Starliner missions, leaving ULA in a "cash-strapped" state. Add in this new issue involving propellant management and the complicated plumbing that feeds liquid oxygen and methane to the BE-4 engines. It's looking like Vulcans won't be flying for several months.





















