Two weekends ago, I did a small update on things going on in my shop, both Saturday and Sunday (with more pictures). The two general directions are either a more complicated and functional internal combustion engine vs. something more beautiful but still functional, like an orrery.
Much of the intervening two weeks have been spent doing grown-up or homeowner shit, as we're speeding into summer and there are things that need the attention. The exception has been something I stumbled across while doing something else. It's called the Antikythera mechanism.
I'd heard of the Antikythera mechanism before, but hadn't thought about it in longer than I can recall. It turns out to be rather interesting for a few reasons. It's an ancient Greek device recovered in 1901 from a shipwreck in the Greek Islands dated to approximately 100 BCE give or take 30 years. The most succinct description of it might be that it's the world's oldest analog computer. The "world's oldest" by a thousand years. If you'd like to be more specific, the kind of analog computer that best describes it is that it's an orrery.
To borrow from the online Encyclopedia Britannica:
The Antikythera mechanism had the first known set of scientific dials or scales, and its importance was recognized when radiographic images showed that the remaining fragments contained 30 gear wheels. No other geared mechanism of such complexity is known from the ancient world or indeed until medieval cathedral clocks were built a millennium later.
The Antikythera mechanism was fabricated out of bronze sheet, and originally it would have been in a case about the size of a shoebox. The doors of the case and the faces of the mechanism are covered with Greek inscriptions, enough of which survive to indicate clearly much of the device’s astronomical, or calendrical, purpose. It is believed that a hand-turned shaft (now lost) was connected by a crown gear to the main gear wheel, which drove the further gear trains, with each revolution of the main gear wheel corresponding to one solar year. On the front of the mechanism is a large dial with pointers for showing the position of the Sun and the Moon in the zodiac and a half-silvered ball for displaying lunar phases. The drive train for the lunar position is extremely sophisticated, involving epicyclic gearing and a slot-and-pin mechanism to mimic subtle variations (known as the “first anomaly”) in the Moon’s motion across the sky. (See Hipparchus and Ptolemaic system.)
With something as famous as this, you might expect to find many pictures of reconstructions of it in everything from wood, to plastics (including in Legos) to intricate metal versions of it. Some of those make the effort to recreate the final form and function of the Antikythera mechanism while others just emulate the functions. This is a deep, deep rabbit hole to dive into.
An example. You can be sure the 100 BC Greeks didn't have plexiglass (or whatever that clear plastic is), but it's an impressive model.
Image Credit: Eternal Gadgetry
There's this metal model on Instructables (design sharing), a 3D Printed model at Printables (Prusa), and another 3D printable on Thingiverse.
And this illustrates only the gearing:
Image credit: Communications of the ACM - figure 14 here. Not that I could sit down with this and figure out what it should look like. Besides, it shows you there are 65 gears but nothing about their sizes and numbers of teeth.
Is this the next project? I honestly don't know. I like it, but 65 gears of unknown sizes strikes me as a lot for a first project cutting gears. What's cool about this is the historical aspect. That first orrery video I posted Saturday the 12th still seems pretty good (that links to the full video, not just the last few seconds). I need to start looking closer at options. Once I get my sprinkler system fixed. And the other stuff.
Beware of the size of the rabbit hole that you are thinking about going down, however, this guy has already dropped in: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dRXI9KLImC4&list=PLZioPDnFPNsHnyxfygxA0to4RXv4_jDU2
ReplyDeletegreat minds think alike
DeleteIf you're really considering building a copy of the Antikythera Mechanism, then I recommend the YouTube channel Clickspring.
ReplyDeletehttps://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZioPDnFPNsHnyxfygxA0to4RXv4_jDU2&feature=shared
Chris built a copy of the mechanism. While he used a small lathe - complete with some CNC capability for gear cutting, and a milling machine, he also did some of the operations in ways that we think may have been available to the ancient craftsman. The playlist is long, but interesting, and one of the later videos goes into detail about the lunar/solar calendar in use at the time
In the 2nd video of his playlist he does reference a site that was supposed to have the gear data, but when I looked it was basically dead.
Still, the videos show how he built his replica and I think they show all of the gearing, or he may know where that gearing data is currently available.
His channel is fairly interesting if you like the machinists work. Chris is more of a clockmaker, as his stuff is mostly small. But he does beautiful work
DeleteThanks to both of you for the info. It's a neat looking channel. I just watched the first video, linked in your first comment, Anon (I assume it was you).
DeleteYou mention Clickspring cutting gears on a CNC lathe with a rotary table. Ken Toons, who did the Zeamon orrery video I've linked to a few times, is definitely running the same Sherline lathe I made into a CNC lathe some years ago with the same (CNC'ed) Sherline rotary table I have. It just seems like the way to do it. There's dozens of steps he does that don't involve CNC. I think the milling machine I've seen Toons use is the same small CNC Sherline mill I have.
Like I said, it seems a bit overwhelming, but I'm not sure any of the others I've looked at aren't the same. Sometimes the most effective way to learn to swim really is to get thrown off a boat. Same thing with cutting 65 gears by "diving into it."
I've always been fascinated by the Antikethera Mechanism. What really gets me though is the uniqueness of the device - such a complex mechanism can't have been created as a one-off. Surely there should have been precursor devices, prototypes if you will or other initial versions. And then, such a useful and valuable device/technology simply disappears.
ReplyDeleteAn interesting comment I ran across while madly searching for things was someone saying (loosely quoted) that if the Greeks really understood what they had created and thought about the other things they could do with it., they'd have been on the moon in 300 years. Hard to think that wasn't to shock modern readers - there's so much technology that had to be developed - but it stuck in my head.
DeleteIt is endlessly fascinating - and to your point SiG, surely cannot have been the only that existed. Although I suppose, given the times, more could have existed but simply not have survived anywhere we can find them. The fragility of the device perhaps also argues against its long term survival. And surely, if any workshops were conquered or looted, likely those doing the conquering and looting would not have likely realized the value. At best, it would have been more bronze to melt down.
DeleteSo much opportunity lost.
ReplyDeleteThis can't have been the only one It can't have been the first one. Where is the bench?
ReplyDelete