Wait. What?
The headline at Ars Technica reads, "Google turns to Blue Origin for a rocket, but its long-term problem remains" and my first thoughts were along the lines of "A rocket? They're not even flying. They must be talking years in the future." The first sentence says the launch will be in 2029, so that does sound more feasible than saying they're going to launch in '27, but not necessarily a sure thing. In my mind, New Glenn hasn't proven itself. ULA's Vulcan has had four launches including the two that had SRB issues but the system was able to compensate for the problem. Until Sunday's failure, I thought the Vulcan was closer to proven out - at least proven to more of an extent than New Glenn. New Glenn had three launches, two of them successful, before the fourth blew up on the launch pad back in May. Now I look at both of them as highly experimental.
Google's aim is something called Project Suncatcher.
Google disclosed it was working on scalable orbiting data centers about a year ago and characterized the project as one of its research “moonshots.” The mission on New Glenn is designed to deploy satellites, each with computing capacity at roughly the scale of a data center rack, into Sun-synchronous orbit where they can receive nearly continuous solar energy.
“Project Suncatcher is a long-term moonshot to scale AI infrastructure in space by tapping into the abundant solar power in orbit,” said Travis Beals, senior director of Project Suncatcher at Google, in the news release. “This dedicated launch with Blue Origin represents a crucial milestone on our roadmap as we expand the boundaries of what’s possible for the future of compute.”
The Project Suncatcher launch will fly on the 7x2 variant of the New Glenn, not the 9x4 variant we've been writing about lately, and the 7x2 is the only variant that has flown so far. It has had three missions and two were successful. It's entirely an assumption, but it's expected that this is a "proof of concept" mission for Project Suncatcher.
The question that "none dare ask" is if Google or anyone can commit to orbital data centers without having their own dedicated, heavy lift, launch vehicle. It's practically a law of the business that without low-cost, heavy lift capability, there is no way that data centers in space can be economically competitive with terrestrial data centers.
Upon announcing Project Suncatcher a year ago, Google said it was planning for the mid-2030s, when launch costs are projected to drop to as little as $200 per kg. The only rocket likely capable of reaching those costs during the next decade is SpaceX’s Starship vehicle, but in recent months it has become clear that SpaceX will prioritize its own payloads (including Starmind data centers) on Starship. For Google to reach its target price of $200 per kg, it would likely require a fully optimized Starship V4 (the company is currently flying a V3 Starship) that reaches a lift capacity of approximately 200 metric tons to orbit.
Perhaps Google is planning a partnership with Blue Origin to take advantage of the 9x4 New Glenn variant, but that still leaves them between a rock and a hard place. Blue Origin is planning its own orbital data center constellation, Project Sunrise. It seems rather easy to predict that when they get that started, they'll be like SpaceX in using the majority of their heavy lift capability for their own data centers. I can imagine that some other company may go down the road of developing a heavy lift rocket, but that has historically been very expensive. SpaceX has spent more than $15 billion and a decade of time developing Starship, according to its 2026 securities filings. Blue Origin has likewise invested billions and a decade in developing New Glenn.
The New Glenn rocket rolls to LC-36 in preparation for its third launch. Credit: Blue Origin
Final words from Eric Berger at Ars Technica:
At this point, Google has some not-great options. It can hope that one of the newer US launch companies steps up for commercial satellite operators and decides not to pursue its own constellation. It could buy one of those newer launch companies. Or Google could hire some rocket scientists to start developing powerful rocket engines and begin chasing SpaceX and Blue Origin in launch—both of which have a 25-year head start.

No comments:
Post a Comment