Eric Berger at Ars Technica took on a pretty mundane topic over at Ars Technica, but managed to blow my mind in the setup. The topic, the kind that's always a matter of opinion, is to rank the 25 coolest things in space so far in this century. The subtitle, though, is the thing that kicked me in the head: “Taking stock of spaceflight one-quarter of the way through the 2000s.” That's right, in three weeks, New Year's Day 2025, we're 1/4 of the way through the 21st century. Sure, it's obvious when you think about it, I just never gave a moment of thought to it.
It's an interesting read, far more interesting than the typical end-of-the-year retrospectives we get every year for New Year's, and I wouldn't dream of picking 25 things just to match the number of years but it might be fun to think about the top 10 coolest things.
10: The Voyagers continue in interstellar space
I write about the two voyagers regularly, whenever a story comes up. Pretty much every time, the problems are things never seen before. Components are working at temperatures they never were certified for; and that's true for every system on the pair of satellites. The team that got Voyagers started on the mission have all retired or passed away, replaced by younger engineers and techs that have to work on things that they must have confidence won't do something awful because of the two day delay between sending a command and getting results back. This coming August and September will mark their 48th year in their four year mission.
9: New Horizons Pluto Mission
On January 19, 2006, at 1900 UTC, Mrs. Graybeard and I were riding our bikes home from a moderately long bike ride and interrupted our ride to watch a rocket arc downrange (saying the ride was moderately long is based purely on where we pulled off the side of the road to watch it). It was the Atlas V carrying New Horizons as it started its mission to fly by Pluto. The flyby was on July 14, 2015 - close to 9-1/2 years travel. It was the first time since the Voyagers in the 1980s that a probe reached a planet never-before seen in such resolution. No one knew what to expect and the images were jaw dropping.
8: Philae touches down on a comet
Built by the European Space Agency, Philae was a small robotic lander that traveled to a distant comet, 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, aboard the Rosetta spacecraft. After a journey of about a decade, Rosetta reached orbit around the comet and released Philae. In November 2014, Philae touched down on the comet, but harpoons designed to anchor the spacecraft failed to deploy. Accordingly, Philae bounced a few times before coming to a soft landing on the nucleus.
This marked the first time a spacecraft had ever landed on a comet. Although lying on its side in the shadow of a steep cliff, Philae still returned rich data about the comet’s nucleus over the next half year or so. It returned images and video from a comet that were at once familiar but also entirely alien.
7: 20 Years of Continuous Exploration on Mars
Since 2004, there have been rovers continuously exploring on Mars, starting with Spirit and Opportunity and continuing through Curiosity in 2012 and 2020’s Perseverance. The continuous ability to observe and monitor conditions on Mars goes beyond the headline, “search for evidence of life” on Mars to a continuous ability to observe Mars, which could benefit plans to settle on the world.
Part of the “coolness factor” of 20 years on Mars includes the
Ingenuity helicopter and its 72 flights out of a planned 5. Ingenuity is almost worthy of a spot of its own in the Top 10
coolest.
6: Kepler Space Telescope finding planets
The existence of planets outside our solar system was confirmed in the 1990s, but the launch of the Kepler Space Telescope in 2009 changed that picture. The first planets were detected by monitoring the brightness of stars for periodic dips in brightness that would indicate a planet blocking (occulting in astronomer-talk) the star by passing between the telescope here and the star.
Kepler did the same, monitoring the brightness of approximately 150,000 main sequence stars in our neighborhood of the Milky Way Galaxy, looking for the periodic brightness dips to identify transiting planets. To date, Kepler has detected more than 2,700 exoplanets and found that far from being rare, there are probably at least as many planets in our galaxy as stars, if not many more. In case it’s not immediately clear, 2,700 has to be a lower limit to the number of exoplanets for two reasons: first, if the plane of the orbit doesn’t line up right, we’ll never see the occultation, and second, if the orbital period is more years than Kepler was able to observe, we’ll never see it.
5: The James Webb Space Telescope
Another example of late and over budget, but that’s far more understandable
for something never done before, like the JWST, than something that’s almost
completely reuse of existing hardware like SLS. JWST is a self-deploying
multi-mirror infrared (IR) telescope that was bound for an orbit that nothing
can reach if the telescope needed to be fixed. A high risk mission.
After lifting off on an Ariane 5 rocket on Christmas Day 2021, the
telescope spent half a year unfolding and deploying in space before finally
beginning operations. But the astronomical results have been worth it. The
saga of Webb has been a story of persistence and perseverance by NASA,
Northrop Grumman, and other partners who strived to bring this magnificent
instrument online. A happy ending was far from certain, but we got one anyway.
4: The first successful landing of an orbital class rocket
I remember this one vividly. It was the night of December 21, 2015, from
Cape Canaveral and we were watching from the backyard while listening to the
Kennedy Space Center Amateur Radio Club live relay on their 2 meter repeater.
The landing was below our horizon but we could see the engine burns in the
night sky and hear the radio coverage. It seemed like Sci-Fi for a
rocket that had just launched a few minutes earlier to return and land near
the launch site. Like many people, we had paid attention to the attempts to
land on a barge at sea, and while we were hopeful, those weren’t all that
encouraging. That landing changed everything, and the first recovery at sea
was in April 8, 2016.
I could go on about how important reuse is, but I’ve done that too much
already.
The rest of what follows is all SpaceX.
3: Demo 2 and America's return to manned spaceflight
By the spring of 2020, we had gotten used to SpaceX landing Falcon 9 boosters
and their seemingly incredible rate of progress. On the other hand,
since the last Shuttle flight in 2011, NASA had seemingly been sliding
backwards, forced into buying rides to the International Space Station from
the Russians. Sliding backwards, that is, until SpaceX’s Crew Dragon
came along.
The
vehicle’s first mission, carrying Doug Hurley and Bob Behnken, came during a summer of unrest when
America needed a win. The country was still largely shut down by COVID-19, and
its politics were fractured by the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis on
May 25. America’s return to human spaceflight marked a significant technical
achievement by SpaceX, which became the first private company to launch humans
into orbit, and it allowed NASA to fly more astronauts to the space station
and take full advantage of that facility's research capabilities. Dragon has
flown more than a dozen times since.
2: Falcon Heavy with a choreographed landing of two boosters
Choreographed for the two Falcon 9 boosters to land about one second and a few
hundred feet apart on the Cape. This Falcon Heavy launch, in February of
2018 took the #1 spot in Eric Berger’s polls of readers that he did to write
his piece. It was a visual candy treat – irresistible. It starts
with the 27 Merlin engines of the three strapped-together Falcon 9s, then that
choreographed landing, and is topped off with the arresting view of a cherry
red Tesla (and Starman) flying away from Earth and out toward Mars.
It was a spectacle that understandably captured the public’s attention. But
the new rocket was more than a spectacle. By designing, building, and
launching the Falcon Heavy, SpaceX demonstrated that a private company could
independently fund and fly the largest and most powerful rocket in the world.
This showed that commercial, heavy-lift rockets were possible. By providing
competition to the Delta IV Heavy, the Falcon Heavy saved the US government
billions. It's likely that the US government will never design and develop a
rocket ever again.
1: Catching the massive superheavy booster with the launch tower at Starbase
I’m rating this as the coolest thing in the first quarter of the 21st Century
while Eric Berger at Ars Technica rated it #11. Everyone knows the
visual impact from having watched replays over and over again, I guess I’m
just more impressed by that little demonstration.
On October 13 of this year, SpaceX launched its massive Starship rocket for the fifth time, but this
flight profile was different in that the company sought to recover the Super
Heavy first stage. Remarkably, the rocket returned to the launch site, hovered
alongside the launch tower, sidled into the space between the pair of massive
“chopsticks” then was plucked from the air by them and subsequently set down
back on the launch mount.
There are a few reasons why this is such an important event. It demonstrates a
number of important things. First, it verifies the radical approach to
catching a rocket (obviating the need for landing legs and reducing launch
turnaround times). It allows SpaceX to accelerate the development and testing
of Starship. Finally, the visually stunning tower grab captured the
public’s attention and brought wider recognition of Starship’s potential to
change spaceflight forever. In the first few weeks after the mission I
heard more people who aren’t particularly interested in day to day space
activities talking about how incredible this was, saying things like “Elon
Musk makes towers that grab flying rockets out of the air” or talking about
how it’s the most fantastic thing they’ve heard about since the moon
landings.
And there you have it. Lists like the Top 10 of anything are always one person's opinions and I'm sure few, if any, of you will agree with mine. I'm still not tired of watching Falcon 9s land after a successful flight, and I still stop to watch highlights of the flight test with the booster being grabbed by the chopsticks. There were some cool things in Eric's list I couldn't replicate, but he had the top 25 (for 25 years) and I stopped at 10.
Feel free to voice any opinions, as always.
Ad Astra!
ReplyDeleteSiG, that is a great list. The fact that most of those things sort of pass under the radar on a daily basis shows how jaded we have become to going to space at all.
ReplyDelete20 years of continuous exploration of Mars? I can remember when we still thought about maybe going there to look at all.
Number 2 is my favorite on your list. Engineering for the win!
ReplyDeleteIntercepting and landing on an asteroid orbiting another asteroid, the asteroids unattached to and only transiting through solar systems, then returning samples to earth as the mother ship darts off to intercept yet another asteroid boggles my mind like not thing else.
ReplyDeleteI rate that mission right up there with the Vgers.
Two comments, if I may:
ReplyDelete1. in #3: "...were fractured by the killing of George Floyd..."
I might have preferred the word "death" to "killing"
I guess it's a good thing I wasn't on the jury in Derek Chauvin's trial; the level of fentanyl (alone) in George Floyd's body would have killed a very healthy man half his age.
2. I always read and carefully evaluate Toirdhealbheach Beucail's comments, but again, if I may, "tho(e)se things (really don't) sort of pass under the radar on a daily basis"
were the media to place "these things" in a front page position, the general population might be clamoring for Congress to spend (far) more money on space exploration than it does on social welfare projects;
it would give people the chance to cast their eyes outward and towards the future as opposed towards their navel and what (might) have happened in the past.
John Doe becomes a part of what happens and his children become anxious to become a part of our future diaspora (dispersion, if you prefer) to the stars - ad astra indeed
When Google Space came out, they blacked out a classified section of the sky, and no one would talk about it.
ReplyDeleteIf it's still there, it'd probably be #1.
I have a minor quibble about Number 9; The Cassini-Huygens mission to Saturn came after the Voyager missions and before the Pluto mission.
ReplyDeletehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassini%E2%80%93Huygens
I spent far too much time that I could have spent painting Warhammer figures looking at photos taken by Cassini as it danced it's way through the Saturnian system...sigh.
YMMV
I'm with you SGB, catching that booster and doing it the first attempt, yeah, 1st place all day. Just the gargantuan size of the whole system is breathtaking. To see that many tons of supersonic stainless steel and explosive methane/LOx come screaming in like king kongs lawn dart, and then brake to single digit mph, then walk in and be aligned within fractions of an inch, and settle on the arms like it weighed as much as a potato chip, all the things which had to work right and what tolerances they had to work with, its a feat for a century no uncertain terms. A feat of engineering, vision and daring do. The coolest thing I ever witnessed. It was totally fun to top all that up. Just the pure delight of its success makes it a top choice alone.
ReplyDeleteBut yet, thats not even close to how fantastic an engineering achievement it is. It is the hidden attributes and advantages of the holistic idea of stage zero and being able to turn around in time it requires to do safety check, re-stage a full 2 stage rocket, fuel that monster up, an blast off, in what, 2 hours tirn around if go for next flight? And if there is a problem either stage can be swapped out in jig time, ready to fly. That is hugely transformative. You can bet a right arm the Chinese did not miss any of that and will copy cat it soon as those guys can make it work. That is in its way a pretty great compliment.
Its gonna be the hairiest ride in spaceflight history being the first person to fly on a manned starship catch attempt. Been wanting to see who it is has the balls to volunteer for that.