A couple of GB-22 posts ago, I asked how to go about testing something like this. The suggestion that made the most sense to me was to pop the bullet out of .22LR round, dump the powder and just see if I can pop the primer. Sounds like a plan.
But first I had to build it. Rude mistake/awakening: none of the ballpoint pen springs I could find were long enough. They also wouldn't drop the firing pin all the way. About the same time, I was going through the prints for the umpteenth time looking for hints on what the spring needs to be. In the original drawings Mark Serbu put down two numbers with the spring. I just assumed it was some sort of in-house number for the spring, but then asked myself why there would two numbers. A web search for the two numbers revealed that one of them was an MSC stock number for a spring. They came in bag of 12, which I had to order. I was able to assemble the gun. All except for one last thing I'll get to.
There are two real differences between my
implementation of the GB and Mark's: the firing pin and the barrel. Mark used a 1/16" dowel pin for the pin. Not wanting to play the shipping-costs-more-than-the-hardware game, and having a box of 100 1/8 dowel pins, I figured I'd grind one of them down. It's pretty symmetrical, and centered in the hole.
The other difference between my version and Mark's is that he didn't
use a separate barrel: he rifled the 2-1/2" long front piece of
steel and reamed a chamber. I am not set up to rifle barrels, so
I bought one. That raised the issue of just where to seat the barrel. Mark's
drawing shows the back of his barrel chamber recessed for the rim, so
that the round would be flush. Re-watching his videos a bunch of times,
the shell appears to be sitting on that surface, not flush with the back. I spent a while with some fired .22 brass trying to hold the barrel in varying positions
and see where the pin seemed to make a good solid dent. Not surprisingly, it
seemed to be best when the barrel was farther back. I epoxied the barrel into the rectangular barrel holder so that the back of the chamber is flush with the holder.
Old joke in quality control: Designer puts a note on drawing "Build in
accordance with MIL-TFP-41C". QC Inspector says, "What Milspec is TFP-41C?
I've never heard of that". Designer replies, "Make It Like The F***ing
Plans For Once!" I didn't follow MIL-TFP-41C.
With the GB-22 now built, it was with some trepidation and excitement that I pulled a .22 bullet, dumped the primer and chambered the brass. I pulled back the slide, pulled the trigger and ... nothing. No pop. Tried again. Nothing. Thinking I should verify that I didn't somehow dislodge and dump the primer, I put it in a junky old .22 revolver I have, and it popped with one hammer drop. No primer issues; the problems are purely with the GB-22. With no other information, I pulled another .22 round apart and repeated. On the third hammer drop, the round popped. So one successful primer pop out of five or six trigger pulls.
Before I'd be comfortable taking the gun on the 40 minute drive to the my range, I'd like to resolve a couple of issues. The first one is the obvious: it shouldn't take five slide drops to fire a round. I notice in the YouTube videos that it's not that unusual to need to pull the trigger twice. That would be a big improvement. The second things is the general fit of the slide. If I tighten the 10-32 screws in the slide all the way, the slide won't move. That sounds like there are some burrs or "something sticking up" on the slide that's keeping it from sliding. The two of these together sound like general "fit or function" improvements. I have some troubleshooting to do before it's actually usable.
I have to give you major props for even taking on this little project in the first place and thank you for sharing your progress.ReplyDelete
One thing that came to mind when you mentioned that tightening the screws binds the action up is just how similar that is to the gib screws on the compound slide for my mini lathe. There is a fine line there. That also brings to mind many threads and opinions I have since read about dealing with sticky/ binding metal parts that slide against each other.
They are myriad to put it mildly but one suggestion I might make would be to oil the hell out of it while running it back and forth twenty or so times. That might give you a "shiny spot" or two to see if it is a high spot giving you trouble. As for the spring, and pin, I'm wondering if the pin is actually traveling far enough?
I'm sure you will dink with it and figure it out but I am pretty damn impressed with what you have accomplished already!
Thanks for the kind words. This project is around 75% learning experience. The mill is capable of breaking shit in an "ohnosecond". Things that would stall my Sherline won't even slow this one down, so I'm learning lots of lessons about fixtures and holding the work.Delete
I figure I'll keep learning as long as I keep trying to make things. I just hope to break fewer tools and ruin fewer parts. I have tremendous respect for manual machinists, tool and die makers, and mechanics.
The pin's travel is set by the dimensions of the parts. It's glued into the middle piece of the slide, and the length it can move is set by the overall design. It's either losing force due to drag holding it down, or maybe I need a stronger spring. A simple test is to wrap some rubber bands around the slide and the front of the barrel holder. Slam that dude down faster and harder. First, though, I'm going to make sure the frame is free of burrs and crap.
My boy was into RC (Radio Controlled) cars for a while. The local shop has all kinds of spring/strut assemblies. They come in many sizes. One nice thing about a strut assembly is that the spring is pre-loaded and contained. It won't go squirting all over the place when you try to assemble it.ReplyDelete
You might look around and see if you have any RC shops in your area.
If you had done the 12 gauge zip gun like I suggested, you wouldn't need no steenkin' springs! And all you need is a solid backing block for the breech and it won't be going nowhere. And it would be far more impressive to your rangemates than a piddly little .22lr...ReplyDelete
Glad to see you're making progress!
Truth be told, I'm remarkably ignorant about all the moving parts in a modern gun. This is a learning experience.Delete
It's really the first step in a bunch of expected projects.
Got my first rifle in 1964. Wasn't long before I took it all apart to figure out what makes it go. Been doing that ever since. Firearms are fascinating in the array of mechanisms you run into.ReplyDelete
Looks to me like your firing pin strikes are both too weak and too far from the rim. The priming compound needs to be crushed inside the rim.
I have access to bins full of springs of all types. Give me a diameter and length so I can find several with different wire gauge and strength (if I locate what you need, will contact for delivery addy.ReplyDelete
Decent build! Sounds like you have something robbing energy from the spring...those are VERY light primer strikes. And the tightness of the screws on the slide shouldn't matter unless you didn't pay attention to Flag Note 3 on G2228000. A quick fix is to pull on the spring to make it's initial length longer.ReplyDelete
I was never able to overcome the excessive losses and get it to fire reliably, although I did get it to strike quite a bit harder. It never got better than one firing on five drops of the slide.Delete
I found that the 3/16" steel I bought for the center of the slide was thinner than the 3/16" steel I got for the frame. I eventually milled the frame down to get it all ".003 to .010 under" the thickness of the center section of the slide. It should be between .185 and .178. It's virtually all there; if anything, it's a little too thin in the middle of the top.
It has become a "one of these days" project.