On my amplifier repair and trying to recover from the lightning strike. The last update I posted, back on the 13th, I was optimistic. Since then, I've gotten a bit more discouraged.
Some deep technical stuff about the PW1 follows.
The amplifier package is about one third power supply by volume and is what many technicians would call a "blivet," defined as 10 pounds of shit in a 5 pound package. The story you'll see on ham radio forums is that if your power supply is bad, be prepared to pay half the price of a new amplifier. The amplifier weighs about 60 pounds and would cost a lot to send to the factory service guys. I read that as spending a lot just to find out how much I have to spend.
My goal here has been to get the amplifier to turn on so
that I can see if it still amplifies. That's more hope than realistic
expectation, but the alternative is to spend (guessing) $150 to $175 to ship it
both ways, and then probably run up a total close to the price of a new
amplifier to get it fixed. Another reason for the hope is that no other piece of radio gear was damaged in its radio portion. In my main radio, the only damage was my USB port getting blown out. No other radio had any damage.
When you first look at the schematics, it's not even clear how the thing gets turned on. It has a remote control head (pictured in that link above) with small on/off switch - certainly not a switch that will handle 240 VAC at high current. There's a small power supply in the main box that's on any time the amplifier is plugged in. That supplies 15V to the remote head, where it switches a couple of logic circuits that tell the main box to turn on everything. At first it seemed possible that only that supply was damaged, then it seemed only things attached to the 220V AC line were damaged.
I'm sure I've said a bunch of times that the problem is I have no documentation on circuit details. At first, I had no schematics at all, but was later able to find a set of schematics that had parts drawn, but no values or part numbers. It's actually worse than that because there's 11 subassembly schematics and not one thing to tell you where those subassemblies are in the unit.
Let me show you what I mean. This is a screen capture of one of those schematics in pdf format. It's the portion on which I most recently replaced a blown part. I deduced where it was in the box by following another few drawings.
The only part numbers on this are in the upper left and I added those. See that 16 pin IC (IC1) in bottom, toward the left center? I have only the vague idea that it's "some sort of voltage regulator" but without knowing more about it, probably by looking up a datasheet online, I don't know how to tell if it's working or not.
This turns out to be the heart of the high voltage supply. The last thing I posted about was that while the lower voltages seemed OK, the 45V supply wouldn't turn on. When I tested the bridge rectifier (top left) I found it was shorted across any two pins you looked at; what we call a "blob o' silicon" in the biz. Since the bridge had a part number marked on it, I ordered a replacement from one of the big name distributors (Arrow); they came Friday and I installed the replacement on Saturday.
Before that part got here, though, I recognized that there's a logic line going to that board that tells it to turn on the HV supply. I had to go through the five or six pages that signal passes through several times before I realized where it was coming from, but not how to fix turning that line on properly. I figured if I could pull that signal low as a test, it would turn on the HV supply. Once the diode bridge was in place, measuring like real diodes (power off!), I set up to do the experiment of pulling that line low. There was a loud noise and a flash of light, followed by the smell of burned electronics. Uh oh. Once the dust settled, I was able to determine that the parts I've replaced are still fine, and the unit behaves like it did before I grounded that logic line. I just found or created new ones to replace.
I should point out that I had talked with chief technician at the factory service center, the guy who just repaired my main radio (now supposed to be here on the 23rd) about what I had been doing. He said if the RF deck has problems like shorted power transistors and I tried to turn it on, "it will be loud". I think there was a DAMHIK implied.
In our long discussion, he basically said I've spent more time trying to get it to turn on than they would because he doesn't have any more documentation on that power supply than I do. The ironic part is that so far, I've replaced less than $10 worth of parts and have gotten it to power on and look alive. He said, as the forums say, that their standard repair was to replace the power supply and that's about half the price of a replacement unit. They can check the amplifiers with a laboratory power supply and verify them or repair them, then replace the big power supply.
Since I don't have anything that's known good, progress is painfully slow. The most painful part, though, is the uphill struggle of the lack of documentation. My inner motivational speaker reminds me that, "quitting is a permanent solution to a temporary problem." Frankly, the motivational speech isn't doing much for me.
What I haven't mentioned all this time is that I have the ARRL equipment insurance and they do cover this sort of damage. The insurance value is a replacement price that you enter; you decide how much you want for it. After the weekend explosion I figured it was time to call the claims office and see what they said about getting started. I don't know if the guy is a ham, but he was very knowledgeable about the problems I've been facing and suggested I talk to factory service, or anyone with experience with these. He said if a tech said it was worth scrapping, he'd send me a check.
I know how hard it is to let go of a problem like this.ReplyDelete
My advice is to cut your losses and file a claim. Even if Icom repaired it, I'll bet the rest of the electronics in there got stressed somewhat, and you'd always have That Doubt that goes with repaired gear.
You can always go back and tinker with it. I doubt if they'll want it back.
NO! NO! Don't listen to drjim, ride that lost hope down into the ground, sucking fun and time and life itself into it like a black hole, or a boat, or a black hole shaped like a boat, or in this case a black hole shaped like an electronic component...ReplyDelete
Or... Take the check. And as drjim says, if they let you keep the dead one, now you can officially dissect it without worrying about fubaring something, as it's already fubared. Good teaching moment, too.
You're braver than I am even trying this after all the magic smoke got out.ReplyDelete
Sometimes ya just gotta cut your losses. When you're in a hole, the first thing you do is stop digging. If the insurance company will buy you a new one or close, do it!ReplyDelete
And if they don't want the old one, then fiddle with it. But get up and running first.
After recently downsizing into a 34' toy hauler I had a ginormous pile of projects. Some I sold and some I gave away and some I sold as scrap. Is your goal to have a functional communication system or the chops from repairing something a professional bench technician couldn't/wouldn't?
Is your goal to have a functional communication system or the chops from repairing something a professional bench technician couldn't/wouldn't?Delete
The first one - have the old station running.
I was trying to get it running to see if I could tell if it was totaled or just had a few parts blown. If it ran now, and got fixed with like $15 in parts changed (alright, $30 including shipping) it would be incredible to have fixed it instead of buying a replacement power supply. What I'm finding is that it seems to be totaled. Even if I fixed it, what got overstressed and is going to die too soon?
True... That first surge may not be a knockout punch but after a few surges it's like boxer getting a few chin shots. You just don't know which one is gonna be a few millivolts over threshold voltage then it's gonna hit the mat faster than a punch drunk boxer.Delete
Btw, I'm an avid lurker. Love your blog.
If you can you email me the model number, a set of schematics, or post the link where they can be found perhaps I can assist. I had written a long winded set of troubleshooting recommendations a while back but never was posted, as I since determined when I send a comment using Safari via iphone you never get them. Anyhow I am a now retired old timer a few hours south of you with 50 years of electronics experience most recently in power electronics and utility scale voltage regulators. Japanese designers sometimes draw schematics in most unfriendly ways. but the page posted is clean and straightforward. Anyway if I can help you fix the beast I will be happy to try. In between a retired husbands do list I have time to work on my toys. Anyway DC coupled transistor circuits are happy to destroy every transistor in the chain when given the opportunity either by itself or by technician induced failure.
From the page suplied its a straightforward full wave capacitive input power supply with inductor followed by a shunt regulator with a feedback loop. IC 1 is a voltage regulator with multiple sense inputs and an output. That little monster may be a proprietary device but its function can be simulated by variable resistors, a resistive load on the power supply and often helpful is an appropriately sized variac on the ac input.
Between the iron weight in the power tx and the filter inductors it spells big dollars on shipping, money better spent on a repair at home.
There was a big change in the situation after posting this. An email to this account gave me a link to the mythical 2010 version of the service manual, which does include the power supplies and schematics with values. Now I have pretty much all the documentation.Delete
If you'd go over to my email, SiGraybeard at gmail dot com (with the obvious descrambling) I can tell you more.
Now just as long as there aren't any damaged unobtainium parts, you might get it running again.
Today I came across a paper on improving the power supply of the IC-PW1 amplifier. The link is below. I cannot vouch for the modifications as I do not have a PW1, or any other amplifier for that matter. I became licensed in December with a General Class, and and haven't yet been able to find the time to string up some wire and clear a desk for a radio. So after first becoming interested in radio and electronics at age 13, and after a long career in the electronics and electric power industry, I finally took the time to take the exam after retiring in July.ReplyDelete
PW1 Mods: https://www.ab4oj.com/icom/pw1/psu_repair.html
Also what may be of interest to readers is a Bell Labs film on wave behavior. Its quite interesting.
Bell Labs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DovunOxlY1k&t=114s
With regard to the lightning hit you experienced, I was wondering if you could share with us the lightning protection and grounding scheme that was in place when the hit occurred, and how you may have improved the protection scheme ?
The delay in posting this comment is due to all comments over 2 weeks requiring approval. That means I basically get them out of the trash to post. I virtually never get a comment to a post older than two weeks that's not SPAM.Delete
The paper on Adam's site (AB4OJ) is one of my permalinks. I've used it a dozen times.
The last question is too long to get into here, but might be worth a post. The problem from the lightning was all induced voltages. It hit my tree, after all, not the radio tower or the house itself. The PW1 was killed by a surge on its 220V AC line, which was just wire in plastic jacket lying in the crawlspace (sort of attic). When I got the amp, I couldn't find a surge suppressor designed for 220V outlets and eventually forgot to keep looking. The station radio, the IC-7600, lost one part: its USB interface. That blew because the computer it was attached to blew, because the antenna rotor cable carried the surge down into the shack and blew out the rotor controller, connected to the computer by a serial port.
The trees are long gone, and the ones remaining are even taller than the one that got hit. The lightning protection system hasn't been changed, but that's high on my "get to it" list, especially since it seems we're not getting a winter. This is antenna projects season.